12 Cinnamon Applesauce Ornament Ideas That Make the Whole House Smell Like Christmas

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.

Click to share!

Some ornaments decorate the tree, and some perfume the whole house. Cinnamon applesauce ornaments do both. Two simple ingredients mix into a rich brown dough that rolls and cuts like cookie dough, then dries hard and keeps its warm, spicy smell for years.

Star shaped cinnamon applesauce ornament resting on a spool of white twine on a dark wooden table
Credit – Instagram @bakedbyrachel

One rule before you begin: these ornaments are NOT edible. They look and smell like Christmas cookies, but the dough is mostly cinnamon, often with craft glue added for strength, and it must never be eaten. Keep them away from curious toddlers and pets, and hang them high on the tree.

The classic recipe is 1 cup of smooth applesauce to about 1 cup of ground cinnamon, with a spoon or two more cinnamon as needed until a stiff dough forms. Many makers add 1 to 2 tablespoons of white glue for extra strength. Roll a quarter inch thick, cut shapes, add a straw hole, then air dry for 2 to 4 days or bake low at 200 degrees Fahrenheit for about 2 to 2 and a half hours.

The list opens with three full builds: the classic ornaments step by step, gingerbread men, and simple stars. Then come embossed shapes, big painting batches, extra spiced versions and sweet gift ideas.

Quick Picks

  • Best first batch: Classic Cinnamon Applesauce Ornaments (idea 1)
  • Best with kids: Gingerbread Man Cinnamon Ornaments (idea 2)
  • Best for gifts: Cinnamon Star Ornaments (idea 3)

1. Classic Cinnamon Applesauce Ornaments

Four step photos showing cinnamon dough being mixed, rolled, cut into stars and hearts and finished with twine
Credit – Instagram @kattkearney

Build2 main ingredientsMakes about 20

This is the master recipe everything else on the list uses. Applesauce and cinnamon, with a pinch of cloves if you like, kneaded into a clay like dough. It rolls beautifully between sheets of wax paper, cuts cleanly, and dries into ornaments that smell like the best part of December.

Materials Needed

  • 1 cup smooth applesauce
  • 1 to 1 and 1/4 cups ground cinnamon, plus extra for dusting
  • Optional: 1 to 2 tablespoons white craft glue for strength
  • Optional: 1 teaspoon ground cloves
  • Wax paper or parchment and a rolling pin
  • Cookie cutters
  • A straw or skewer for hanging holes
  • Twine or ribbon

How to Make It

  1. Stir the applesauce and cinnamon together, adding cinnamon a little at a time until a stiff, clay like dough forms. Add the glue and cloves now if you are using them.
  2. Knead the dough for a minute or two until smooth. If it is sticky, knead in more cinnamon. If it cracks, add applesauce a teaspoon at a time.
  3. Roll the dough between two sheets of wax paper to about a quarter inch thick.
  4. Cut shapes with cookie cutters and lift them onto a parchment lined tray.
  5. Poke a hanging hole near the top of each shape with a straw while the dough is still soft.
  6. Air dry on a rack for 2 to 4 days, turning daily, or bake at 200 degrees Fahrenheit for about 2 to 2 and a half hours until hard.
  7. Cool completely, thread twine through the holes, and hang. Store extras in an airtight container.

Tip: Dust your rolling surface and pin with cinnamon instead of flour. Flour leaves white patches on the dark dough, while cinnamon keeps the color rich and adds even more scent.

2. Gingerbread Man Cinnamon Ornaments

Cinnamon applesauce ornaments on a table including gingerbread men, Christmas trees and stars with twine hangers
Credit – Instagram @fullertonkandi

BuildKids favoriteDecorate with puffy paint

Of all the shapes, the gingerbread man is the one kids ask for by name. Cut a tray of them from the classic dough, and once they are dry, let children decorate with white puffy paint cuffs, buttons and smiles. They look like cookies, smell like cookies, and last for years, unlike cookies.

Materials Needed

  • One batch of classic dough from idea 1
  • A gingerbread man cookie cutter
  • A straw for hanging holes
  • Parchment lined tray or a drying rack
  • White puffy paint for decorating (optional)
  • Twine or red and white bakers twine

How to Make It

  1. Make the classic dough and roll it a quarter inch thick between wax paper sheets.
  2. Cut gingerbread men and place them on the tray, spacing them slightly apart.
  3. Add hanging holes with a straw, at the top of the head or through one hand for a tilted hang.
  4. Dry fully, either in the air for 2 to 4 days or in a low oven.
  5. Decorate with puffy paint once the ornaments are completely dry and cool.
  6. Thread twine and hang, or tie one onto each Christmas gift.

Tip: Remind helpers, young and old, that these gingerbread men are decorations only. Set out a real cookie for snacking so nobody is tempted by the wrong tray.

3. Cinnamon Star Ornaments

Many brown cinnamon star ornaments with hanging holes drying on a metal cooling rack
Credit – Instagram @bisousdek

BuildSimple shape, big impactGreat in bundles

Stars are the hardest working shape in the cinnamon dough box. They dry flat, stack neatly, and look right on the tree, on gifts, in a garland or piled in a bowl on the table. Make them by the rack full, the way this maker did with her boys.

Materials Needed

  • One batch of classic dough from idea 1
  • Star cookie cutters in two or three sizes
  • A straw for holes
  • A cooling rack for drying
  • Twine, ribbon or bakers twine

How to Make It

  1. Roll the dough a quarter inch thick and cut as many stars as the sheet allows.
  2. Re roll the scraps and keep cutting until the dough is used up.
  3. Add a hole near one point of each star.
  4. Lay the stars on a rack so air reaches both sides, and dry 2 to 4 days, turning once a day. Or bake low until hard.
  5. Thread twine through the holes and tie simple knots or bows.
  6. Hang a bundle of three stars together on the tree for a fuller look.

Tip: Mixing sizes is the secret. A big star with a small star tied in front of it looks like a set you bought, not a first try.

30% OFFPrintable Christmas bundle with planner, advent activity cards, gift tags and family games

Printable Bundle

Christmas Printable Bundle

Christmas planner, 24 advent activity cards, 36 gift tags, handmade labels, Santa letter and family games.

$9.99$6.99SAVE 30%Instant PDF download
Get the Bundle

4. Embossed Cinnamon Ornaments

Cinnamon ornaments with embossed reindeer and tree patterns next to a carved wooden rolling pin and a red bell
Credit – Instagram @oldesoulacres

A carved embossing rolling pin pressed over the dough leaves reindeer, trees and woodland patterns in the surface before cutting. The finished ornaments look almost carved, and they make the most beautiful handmade gifts in this whole list. The maker threads hers into garlands too.

You’ll need: classic dough, an embossing rolling pin, cutters, and twine.

Best for: Handmade gifts and garlands

5. Cinnamon Trees and Stars on Parchment

Seven cinnamon dough ornaments on parchment paper including Christmas trees, stars and a gingerbread man before baking
Credit – Instagram @stormy_dawnrav

A first timer tray, trees and stars laid out on parchment before drying, shows how forgiving this dough is. The shapes are simple, the edges a little wobbly, and the result still smells and looks wonderful. If you have never made these, start exactly here.

You’ll need: classic dough, tree and star cutters, parchment, and a straw.

Best for: Complete beginners

6. Hand Cut Cinnamon Animal Ornaments

Hand holding a cinnamon dough animal ornament with more cut out stars and trees on a tray behind
Credit – Instagram @craftygirlsnextdoor

No cutter, no problem. This maker cuts animal shapes by hand and with small cutters, working from a double batch of dough: 2 cups of cinnamon to 1 cup of applesauce. Slightly uneven edges are part of the handmade charm, and animal shapes are a hit with little kids.

You’ll need: a double batch of dough, small cutters or a table knife, and ribbon.

Best for: Animal lovers and freehand cutters

7. Star and Heart Ornaments on Bakers Twine

Cinnamon star ornament hanging from pink and white bakers twine with heart ornaments behind and a spool of twine
Credit – Instagram @koester.michelle

Hearts belong in this dough too. This maker uses the applesauce, cinnamon and clove recipe, dries the ornaments slowly in a very low oven, and stores them in an airtight jar between seasons. Tied with pink and white bakers twine, stars and hearts look soft and romantic on the tree.

You’ll need: classic dough with cloves, star and heart cutters, and bakers twine.

Best for: Soft, romantic tree themes

25% OFFPrintable Christmas party games pack with trivia, charades, who's most likely to and gift swap games

Printable Games

Christmas Party Games Pack

9 fun games for family, friends and office parties: trivia, charades, gift swap and more.

$7.99$5.99SAVE 25%Instant PDF download
Get the Games

8. A Big Batch Ready for Painting

About forty small cinnamon ornaments in many shapes spread on parchment on a wooden table, ready for kids to paint
Credit – Instagram @4marie_1994

Forty two ornaments from one session, ready for the kids to paint. When you need ornaments for a class, a church group or a big family, this is the way: cut every shape you own, dry them all, then set out paints and let everyone decorate their own.

You’ll need: two or three batches of dough, every cutter you own, paints, and brushes.

Best for: Classrooms and big family craft days

9. Cinnamon Cutout Ornament Collection

Dark brown cinnamon cutout ornaments drying on parchment including houses, Christmas trees, Santa hats and presents
Credit – Instagram @_kiddiekrafts_

Houses, trees, Santa hats and little presents: a childcare group cut the whole Christmas village from cinnamon dough. Dark, rich color comes from a dough with plenty of cinnamon. Lay them out to dry where small hands cannot reach, because they smell very tempting.

You’ll need: classic dough, house and holiday cutters, parchment, and patience for drying.

Best for: Preschool and childcare groups

10. Extra Spiced Cinnamon Ornaments

Assorted cinnamon ornaments including stars, moons and rounds on parchment with a Happy Holidays greeting
Credit – Instagram @the_smiling_hag

For the strongest scent of all, this maker stirs extra warm spices into the applesauce base: nutmeg, ground orange, vanilla and sandalwood alongside the cinnamon. The ornaments double as natural air fresheners for drawers and closets long after Christmas ends.

You’ll need: classic dough plus extra ground spices you love, cutters, and twine.

Best for: Scent lovers and drawer fresheners

11. Two Ingredient Cinnamon Ornaments

Cinnamon bell and star ornaments tied with red and white twine bows on a dark slate surface
Credit – Instagram @goinggreenwithlisabronner

Equal parts applesauce and cinnamon, nothing else. This simple version dries on a rack in 3 to 4 days or in a low oven, and the maker suggests tying them onto gifts or gluing a magnet on the back for a year round cinnamon scented fridge magnet. A bell and a star with twine bows show the classic finish.

You’ll need: applesauce, cinnamon, cutters, a straw, and festive twine.

Best for: Gift tying and fridge magnets

12. Small Cutter Cinnamon Ornaments

Rustic cinnamon ornaments on parchment including an angel, a rocking horse, stars and a gingerbread man
Credit – Instagram @the.hopewellhomestead

Small cookie cutters give this cottage style set its charm: an angel, a rocking horse, stars and a gingerbread man, all a little rustic at the edges. The maker rolls the dough a full quarter inch and watches the oven so the edges do not curl, which keeps small shapes neat.

You’ll need: classic dough, small cookie cutters, wax paper, and a toothpick for holes.

Best for: Cottage and country Christmas style

Frequently Asked Questions

Are cinnamon applesauce ornaments edible?

No. They are decorations only. The dough is almost half cinnamon, which is far too strong to eat, and many recipes add white craft glue for strength. They smell like food, so store and hang them where young children and pets cannot grab them, and never serve them with real cookies.

How long do cinnamon applesauce ornaments last?

Years. The scent stays strong for a long time and the ornaments themselves keep for many seasons if they are fully dry. Store them in an airtight container or jar in a cool, dry place, with parchment between layers so they do not stick or chip.

Should I air dry or bake cinnamon ornaments?

Both work. Air drying on a rack takes 2 to 4 days with daily turning, and gives the flattest results. Baking at 200 degrees Fahrenheit for about 2 to 2 and a half hours is faster, but watch for curling edges and turn them once. Never use a higher heat to rush them, as the edges scorch and the scent turns bitter.

Why did my cinnamon dough crack or stay sticky?

Sticky dough needs more cinnamon, added a spoon at a time. Cracking usually means the dough was rolled too thin or dried too fast; keep ornaments a quarter inch thick and dry them slowly. Small cracks can be smoothed before drying by dabbing a wet fingertip along the edge.

How do I refresh the scent of old cinnamon ornaments?

Rub the back of the ornament lightly with a drop of cinnamon oil, or store the ornaments in a sealed jar with a few cinnamon sticks for a week before the season starts. A gentle warm up in a low oven for a few minutes also wakes the scent up. Keep scented oils away from children and pets.

Can I paint cinnamon applesauce ornaments?

Yes, once they are fully dry. Acrylic paint and puffy paint both sit well on the dark surface, and white details look especially good, like icing on a cookie. Paint one side at a time and let it dry before flipping. Unpainted ornaments keep the strongest scent.

Final Thoughts on Cinnamon Applesauce Ornaments

Two ingredients, one rolling pin and a house that smells like Christmas for weeks: cinnamon applesauce ornaments might be the best value craft of the whole season. They are simple enough for children, pretty enough for gifts, and sturdy enough to come back year after year.

Mix a batch this week, cut more shapes than you think you need, and tie the extras onto gifts and wreaths. Just keep the trays clearly separate at snack time. These are the best smelling ornaments on the tree, and they are strictly for hanging, not eating.

Click to share!

Amir Ali
Amir Ali

Amir Ali is the founder of HomeDecorEdge, sharing practical and beautiful home decor ideas for apartments, small rooms and family homes.

Articles: 557